Inspiration and news
Show a little empathy!
Even before transformational leadership and psychological safety swept through the corporate world, one thing was clear: If you are emotionally cold as a leader or team colleague, you might achieve short-term results, but in the long run, the mutual willingness to collaborate will disappear. The call for empathy has grown louder, sometimes having an accusatory tone. But what is empa-thy? What is compassion? And how do you avoid pity? Below, you will find answers to these very questions, and you will learn how to take part in the emotional world of others without burning yourself out.
"Empathy means: seeing through the eyes of another, hearing through the ears of another, feeling with the heart of another."
Clarifying the terms to start with
Empathy is the ability to feel the emotions of other people yourself and to understand them. It is thus more than just perception because the same threat-detection and caregiving centres in our brain are activated while our body reacts as well. Usually, two forms of such emotional response are distin-guished:
Emotional empathy: We feel the emotions, often including the suffering, of other people, which resembles an in-stinctive, automatic reaction.
Cognitive empathy: We can intellectually understand the perspective of others without necessarily feeling their emotions, which is why cognitive empathy is closely related to emotional intelligence and repre-sents more of a skill.
To make empathy relationship-building, both emotional and cognitive empathy are required; oth-erwise, emotions are perceived but not understood, or understood but not perceived.
Compassion goes a step further than empathy: it leads to action. I perceive the feelings of others, I can relate to them, and I take action with the goal of offering support. Accordingly, compassion requires mindfulness so that suffering is recognised without becoming overwhelmed by it or remaining too detached.
If the desire to support turns into an involuntary compulsion, into an automatism, compassion becomes pity. II feel the other person’s pain so intensely that I want to solve the problem for them. The other person is disempowered, while you yourself overcompensate and attempt to solve someone else's problems.
In summary: empathy is purely feeling what others feel. Compassion leads to the desire to sup-port, while pity leads to an excessive absorption of suffering and overcompensating for the other person.
Whether it is empathy, compassion, or pity: Confronting the pain of others is exhausting and drains energy, sometimes even leading to empathy burnout and compassion fatigue. Emotional numbness, exhaustion, irritability, and withdrawal are potential symptoms of such burnout, which is commonly found in sectors with high human contact, such as education, healthcare, chaplaincy, but also in blue-light organisations or customer service. Managing empathy, compassion, and pity is therefore a skill to be learned, which is why a few tips and tricks follow below.
Listening as the “Open Sesame” to Empathy and Compassion
First described by the American psychologist and therapist Carl Rogers in 1957, and later brought into its most frequently cited form by the German communication scientist Friedemann Schulz von Thun in 1981, active listening is an often-cited tool for empathy and compassion. It is about put-ting oneself in the other person's shoes, letting go of one's own way of thinking and feeling for a moment. The three steps of active listening, based on Schulz von Thun, are:
Being all ears: While the external signals of full presence are usually mentioned – i.e., eye contact, open body language, or a nod of the head – these are actually the consequence of an internal atti-tude of openness and complete presence. Pausing one's own thoughts, creating an inner emptiness, and connecting with oneself help to improve one's powers of perception. Exhaling, a brief meditation sequence, or another form of presence exercise can help to become com-pletely receptive.
Understanding the content: The core of what is being said should be grasped and mirrored back through paraphrasing. Communicatively, this is about avoiding misunderstandings, while on the relationship level, it involves cognitive empathy. By describing the other person's way of thinking, I can more easily immerse myself in their perspective.
Mirroring the emotional state: By naming and mirroring back observed or suspected feelings, a deeper level of trust is built. This results in emotional empathy or, subsequently, compassion, when help in dealing with the emotions is offered. What is fascinating here is that such a description often creates a healthy distance from the other person's feelings, making pity less likely. By describing what is hap-pening to the other person, I tell myself that the emotional responsibility lies with them.
Otto Scharmer, a lecturer at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, adds a fourth level of lis-tening. Scharmer speaks of non-listening (downloading), factual listening, empathetic listening, and generative listening. In the latter, you become one with the other person, and the resulting connection leads to a deeper mutual understanding and, consequently, to insights and something new. Such a state of consciousness, which according to Scharmer is encouraged by complete presence but cannot be consciously brought about, thus represents the deepest form of empathy and compassion.
All in all, listening in its active form is a gateway into the world of the other person, requiring atten-tion, presence, and openness. I take a brief break from myself, only to return to my own world afterwards with additional understanding and enriched.
Moving from pity to compassion thanks to a coaching mindset
As mentioned, shared feelings create a deep connection, and you often feel the other person's emotions just as intensely yourself. If these involve grief, anger, or disappointment, you might want to take action yourself, solve the problem situation for the benefit of the other person, and feel the associated relief yourself. However, the resulting pity disempowers the other person: I solve problems without having them myself and without having to live with the consequences of the solution. At the same time, taking over the feelings reduces the pressure of suffering for the person concerned. If the other person worries more about the situation than I do, I can sit back and no actions of my own are required. It is therefore even more important to find the way from pity to compassion and to maintain a coaching mindset.
As a coach, I am convinced that the other person already possesses all the necessary capabili-ties, and my task is to support them in finding a first step towards a solution. To achieve this, simi-larly to active listening, the emotional state and the associated challenge are first mirrored back. After a short pause, questions follow such as: "What would help you to deal better with this situa-tion?", "What support do you need – from me or others – to become more capable of taking ac-tion?" or "What has already helped you in a comparable situation in the past?". Such a resource activation usually moves the other person out of a potential victim mentality
Such a compassion strategy has its limits if the other person remains in a state of panic and thus lacks contact with themselves. Suicidal individuals, people in acute states of anxiety, or those with severe depression cannot find the way to their own capabilities and belief in their own efficacy. This is why responsibility for their life is taken over in the short term, for example in the form of concrete assistance. However, this requires appropriate qualifications, and such standing in is the task of specialists, not of friends, team colleagues, or a leader.
What is mine, what is yours – clarifying emotional accountability
Shared suffering is not always halved suffering, especially when empathy and compassion trigger our own memories and their associated emotions. We all carry an emotional backpack filled with both beautiful and challenging moments. When listening to someone with a similar experience, our own feelings resonate, which can either enrich or overshadow our empathy. Becoming aware of this emotional resonance helps to categorise what is ours and what belongs to the other per-son, allowing us to remain capable of taking action. This does not always work out in the heat of the moment and often requires subsequent self-reflection. Yet, in the spirit of active listening, we can describe not only observed emotions but also our own – and perhaps even uncover their origin – to gain clarity on emotional accountability. This may even foster mutual empathy and an even deeper connection, entirely in line with Scharmer's fourth level of listening.
Mental hygiene or the importance of self-empathy
Engaging with another person's emotional world requires perception and presence, but above all, it drains energy. This is why recovery time and mental hygiene are essential parts of empathy and compassion. The strategies for recharging our own batteries are as diverse as we are. Whether it is sport or journaling, meditation or supervision, gardening or knitting – it is about carving out a moment for ourselves, which is effectively an act of self-empathy. We are just as important as the other person; our well-being and our feelings have just as much right to exist as theirs. This is often illustrated by the oxygen mask analogy: If cabin pressure drops during a flight, we must put on our own oxygen mask first before helping others, ensuring we remain fit to act. Reminding our-selves of this regularly, while also acknowledging our own feelings, constitutes self-empathy and helps prevent exhaustion and burnout.
Connecting as human beings
Whether as a leader, a team colleague, or a friend – empathy creates connection, while compas-sion and its associated support drive us to take action. We step away from our own perspective, meet each other as human beings, and are enriched by this contact. This may be one reason why "compassionate leadership" is described as a highly advantageous management style. Such em-pathetic leadership style is said to lead to higher employee retention and loyalty, increased moti-vation and commitment, as well as greater innovation and creativity. If you do not wait for an offi-cial leadership role but simply practice empathy and compassion in your daily interactions, just as many positive effects will emerge, making working together more joyful and rewarding.
Reflection for you
How do you feel about empathy, compassion, and pity? The following questions will help you sort through your experience.
When and why do you find it easy to put yourself in someone else's shoes?
How do you show and communicate that you understand others?
When does empathy work less well for you, and what might be the reasons for this?
When do you find yourself trying to solve other people's problems out of pity?
What could help you hand the responsibility back to them?
How well are you attuned to your own feelings, and what might help you connect even more deeply with yourself?
What has helped you recover in the past when other people's emotions became too much for you?
At what moments in your life are empathy and compassion particularly needed?
When are empathy and compassion less important, allowing you to focus on other things?
Reflection for you as a team and organization
How do you handle empathy, compassion, and pity as a team and organisation? The following questions will help you evaluate your dynamics. Before starting this reflection, briefly explain what these terms mean and how they differ.
On a scale of 1 to 10, how empathetic do you perceive each other to be? What do you attribute this to?
How much empathy do you feel comfortable with, and what is needed when?
Looking at the scale, what is too much and what is too little?
What helps you strengthen the human connection alongside your professional collaboration?
How can you share feelings in a way that ensures everyone feels comfortable and it remains appropriate?
WWhat is already going well regarding empathy and compassion, and should be preserved?
Where do you see a need for action, and how can this be addressed?
Power and influence? Power and influence!
Whether on stage, in politics, in business, or in our personal lives: Power - understood as the possibility to exert influence - shapes our bilateral relationships as well as the dynamics of a team or group. Those with more power decide what happens and are heard. Those with less power are overlooked, ignored, and must conform.
Use the summer to conduct a team SWOT analyis!
In management consultancy, SWOT analyses are the steppig stone to develop a shared vision of the future. A structured look at internal strengths and weaknesses, as well as external opportuni-ties and threats allows to derive next action steps. However, this analytical tool – developed in the 1950s and well-proven ever since – can do far more than just strategy. Reinterpreted, it becomes a powerful team development tool that highlights potentials and uncovers areas with need for action. Reason enough to perhaps use the quieter summer months for a joint workshop or to re-flect on the team situation through bilateral discussions.
Should I not just speak plainly for once?!
As an organisational developer and process consultant, empathetic neutrality, adjusting to a team’s pace and the ability to change one’s perspective are part of basic skill set: You keep your own opinion to yourself, you do not pull on the growing blades of grass and you step into the shoes of the other person to experience their problem as a challenge of your own. In theory, this makes a lot of sense, in practice as well and yet, there are moments when you think: if someone does not finally speak up, I am going to start screaming.
Don’t worry, be happy!
Who still remembers Bobby McFerrin’s catchy tune “Don’t Worry, Be Happy”, which was played nonstop on the radio, at least during my childhood and teenage years? In the meantime, happiness research has become an integral part of positive psychology, aiming to discover what it takes to live a happy life. Sonja Lyubomirsky’s research is particularly noteworthy in this regard: She interviewed identical twins who were separated at birth and later reunited, in order to determine the genetic influence on feelings of happiness. The resulting findings are fascinating.
I absolutely must find out which bakery my new team likes best so that I can bring the right croissants!
First impressions count – as a job applicant at an interview, just as much as when meeting the team for the first time as a new manager. The choice of croissants suddenly becomes the subject of intense consideration, so that any gluten intolerances or team-specific bakery preferences can be considered.
But: The first impression is just the beginning of Tuckman's team phases of forming, storming, norming and the desired performing. Large German companies such as Bosch and Daimler there-fore consciously invest time in the onboarding process for new managers. Transition workshops with the team and transition coaching with their own line managers are designed to ensure a smooth start in the new role, and the time investment pays off.
Goals and resolutions that are put into practice.
The start of a new year motivates us to think about what is really important to us and what we still want to achieve. The fact that the number of resignations rises from January onwards is an indication of the big decisions that can be made during the festive season. However, it is usually smaller plans that emerge. Surveys confirm that around 60% of Swiss people make New Year's resolutions on New Year's Eve. However, sticking to them and putting them into practice is often difficult once you're back to your everyday routine.
Grazie – Tak – Merci – Dank je – Spasibo – Danke – Gracias – Thank you
Moments of gratitude – throughout the year or especially at Thanksgiving in the USA or at the end of the year in Switzerland – are doing good things for us. What self-help books call “practising gratitude” is described as “counting your blessings” by the English. It refers to the attitude of focusing on what is there, on what is going well. This does not mean denying or ignoring the difficulties. But gratitude for the good things creates the energy and confidence to deal with life’s challenges, too. Research about resilience and happiness has investigated the effect of gratitude, with some exciting insights.
"I'm glad when things remain objective at work. When things get emotional, I always feel a little overwhelmed."
While enthusiasm for the job, commitment to the team and the company as well as contentment about success are desired or even demanded, anger, rage, sadness or helplessness remain unwelcome guests in a professional context. However, as Laloux describes in his book Reinventing Organisations, if you want employees who invest themselves in the company with their minds and hearts, the darker side of emotions cannot be cut away or suppressed. Everything is needed, and studies show that companies with a healthy conflict culture are more innovative and therefore more profitable.
"We want to build a feedback culture in our team!"
Teams and managers come to me with such requests and ask for feedback training: “We want to give each other regular feedback, learn from each other and evolve.” There is often a difference in understanding what feedback is, and when clarifying the request for support, I ask whether feedback is understood as an information on something that I may not yet be aware of (blind spot), or whether it is more about offering criticism with an included desire for behavioural change. Once the understanding of the term has been clarified, the focus of the ‘training’ quickly becomes clearer, and it is usually less about how to give feedback but about building motivation to do so.
"When do you need team development as a team?"
If one has never experienced team development and the associated added value of it, it can remain unclear when a team needs such a team-out. However, the experiences associated with team development are not always positive, as my own first experience many years ago shows: the external facilitator had not been informed about the team-internal conflicts, the day’s agenda was as a consequence chosen inappropriately, the tensions exploded an hour before the end of the day, and on the same evening the team leader resigned.
Maybe that is why it is important to me to repeatedly explain what good team development can be, as I hear too often from teams that a day ended in tears, that individuals felt exposed, or that team dynamics were even worse afterwards. Yet, with the right set-up and the appropriate methods, great things can be achieved.
"Whenever an ambulance drives past me, I know I have to be careful today!"
I remember this statement and the exercise that went as if it was yesterday. 2016 in Berlin on a gloomy Friday afternoon during my training as a change process facilitator. We were given the task of choosing a question that was currently on our minds. To then go outside. To completely clear our minds and connect with the world. “Flirt with the world, and the world will flirt with you!” was the invitation. I do not remember the question I chose, nor do I remember my attempts to flirt with the world. But the subsequent debriefing and the comment made by a fellow participant “When an ambulance passes me on the way to a workshop, I know that today I have to be careful” is still with me today.
"It should be possible to use a few questions to find out where a team's strengths lie and where the areas for development are!"
"It should be possible to use a few questions to find out where a team's strengths lie and where the areas for development are!" A participant in the ETH leadership seminar asked me this in a slightly demanding tone. I thought for a moment and replied: "There are various questionnaires and models for teams and team dynamics, but they each focus on one aspect of a team. As far as I know, there is no collection of questions that looks at a team as a whole. But something like that can be developed.".
Feeling a bit like Heidi Klum!
A little Heidi Klum feeling: an impressive CV and the skills required for the next step in your career. An assessment center as a stopover to achieve this goal. Me as a coach at my side, helping with the preparation and suddenly feeling a little bit like Heidi Klum sending her models onto the catwalk.
Can you kiss the frog prince?
Can you kiss the frog prince? This question stuck with me and I still differentiate between HR and organizational development based on this logic today. While HR development is about helping employees realize their potential and turning them into princesses, organizational development is about a system that cannot be kissed.
"Since I turned my vocation into my profession, working feels like leisure time!"
This feedback pleased me particularly, as I feel the same way since the change into my current role but also because the starting point for the coaching regarding a professional reorientation had not been the easiest: a position that had been achieved through a lot of effort and personal investment, with the prospect of a next career step. Further education in a field that did not immediately promise career change opportunities combined with the desire for more meaning and fulfilment at work.